
Whether a central bank should look through or respond to a supply shock depends on how long the inflationary effects of the shock will last. Yet persistence is often difficult to judge in real time. I find that acting early is preferable because waiting for clarity about persistence could require a larger—and more painful—monetary policy adjustment later.
Supply shocks that cause sharp price increases for goods like food, energy and imports pose a challenge for central banks. Higher interest rates can reduce inflation by lowering aggregate demand. But higher rates cannot fix the root cause of the price increases, such as reduced oil production, disrupted supply chains or higher costs for a foreign supplier. And monetary policy affects inflation with a significant delay.
How central banks respond to inflationary pressures depends in part on how long they will last.
Sometimes the likely duration of a supply shock is reasonably clear, such as a temporary shutdown at a semiconductor factory for planned maintenance. However, in many cases, neither businesses nor the central bank knows how persistent a shock will be when it first hits. This becomes clearer only over time.
Despite this uncertainty, central banks must still set policy. They can choose between two approaches:
- wait-and-see: wait for clear evidence that the shock is persistent before responding
- act now: account for the possibility that the shock will persist when setting the initial policy response, then adjust that response as new information emerges
Using an economic model, I compare the results of these two approaches and find that the second approach performs better on average. Let’s see why.
The persistence of supply shocks shapes the monetary policy response
The inflationary effects of temporary supply shocks tend to fade quickly. Because monetary policy affects inflation with a delay, responding to a temporary shock is often unnecessary and could even be counterproductive.
In contrast, a persistent shock can generate a larger and longer-lasting increase in inflation because businesses have a stronger incentive to raise their prices. Raising interest rates in this instance can mitigate the rise in inflation and help keep inflation expectations anchored to the target at the cost of weakened activity.
To illustrate this point, I use a scaled-down version of the Bank of Canada’s Terms-of-Trade Economic Model. I simulate how inflation, the output gap and the policy interest rate respond to an unexpected price increase for foreign commodities and imported intermediate inputs. Importantly, I assume that all agents in the model—including consumers, businesses and the central bank—know how long the shock will last. Results are shown in Chart 1.
When the shock is known to be temporary, the central bank doesn’t need to react by raising interest rates. By the time the policy change takes full effect in the model—which occurs within 12 to 18 months—the initial shock has largely faded.
However, when the supply shock is known to be persistent, the optimal response is to raise interest rates to return inflation to target. This also causes the output gap to turn negative.
Chart 1: The optimal policy response depends on how persistent a supply shock is
Simulated impact of a foreign supply shock on inflation, the output gap and the policy interest rate
Note: CPI is consumer price index.
Source: Bank of Canada
How long a supply shock will last is often unknown and only becomes clearer over time
In practice, however, central banks must often set policy before knowing whether a shock is temporary or persistent.
To study this problem, I assume that economic agents in the model learn only gradually about the persistence of a shock. Because temporary supply shocks have historically been more common than persistent ones, agents initially view the shock as more likely to be temporary. As new data arrive, agents update their assessments.
If prices quickly begin to reverse, the shock appears temporary. If prices remain elevated, it increasingly appears persistent. Monetary policy adjusts accordingly.
The impacts on the economy and inflation depend on whether the shock ultimately proves temporary or persistent. I simulate both scenarios.
Overestimating persistence has only a modest cost
When the foreign supply shock is temporary though not yet known to be so, the central bank still initially attributes part of the observed price increase to persistent forces. As a result, it raises interest rates rather than looking through the shock (Chart 2). The output gap falls slightly more than it would if the central bank knew from the outset that the shock was temporary.
This effect is relatively modest and short-lived. As it becomes clear that the shock is temporary, the central bank unwinds the initial tightening. Inflation remains close to the path that would prevail if the nature of the shock was known from the outset.
Chart 2: Acting early is relatively inexpensive when a supply shock proves temporary
Simulated impact of a temporary foreign supply shock on inflation, the output gap and the policy interest rate
Note: CPI is consumer price index.
Source: Bank of Canada
Underestimating persistence can be costly for the economy
For a persistent foreign supply shock, I compare the act-now approach with the wait-and-see approach in which I assume the central bank takes one year to conclude that the shock is persistent.
Because the central bank initially views the shock as mostly temporary—and communicates this accordingly—businesses and consumers expect a less aggressive response than would be appropriate for a persistent shock. As a result, inflation rises by more and economic activity remains stronger in the short run than if policy had responded early (Chart 3).
Once the central bank finds the shock is persistent, it must substantially raise interest rates to guide inflation back to the target. This delayed response means the change in monetary policy is larger than if the tightening had happened earlier. It also leads to a deeper contraction in economic activity.
Chart 3: Waiting to respond can be costly when a supply shock proves persistent
Simulated impact of a persistent foreign supply shock on inflation, the output gap and the policy interest rate
Note: CPI is consumer price index. In the scenario Assumed for first year to be temporary, the central bank takes one year to conclude that the shock is persistent.
Source: Bank of Canada
Making policy decisions without full information
In the current global environment, supply shocks are likely to occur more often and last longer than in the past. Persistent shocks pose a trade-off for central banks between restoring price stability and supporting economic activity. Determining the appropriate policy response becomes even more challenging when the duration of a shock’s inflationary effects is uncertain.
This research indicates that initially responding somewhat too strongly to a supply shock that later proves temporary is relatively inexpensive. Policy can be unwound without much impact on economic activity and inflation.
That’s not the case when taking the wait-and-see approach. Holding off on a response gives inflationary pressure more time to build before policy adjusts, requiring a larger—and more painful—adjustment later. When persistence is uncertain, the cost of waiting can exceed the cost of responding too soon.
Disclaimer
Sparks at Bank articles discuss issues relevant to the economy and central bank policy. They are produced independently from the Bank’s Governing Council. The views expressed in each article are solely those of the authors and may differ from official Bank of Canada views.
Find out more
DOI: https://doi.org/10.34989/saba-25